Aliens or Predator: Which marines were best?

[CharlesA222]

Considering that the soldiers in Predator weren't Marines....


I'd say the Marines from Aliens would whup the non-existent Marines in Predator.

[Chris!(($$))!]

The Marines from Predator MIGHT have a chance if they did not waste all their ammo on a tree.

[CHAINS]

The Marines from ALIENS did have the tech but they never got the chance to use it or show their capabilities.They were almost slaughterd because of Gormans mistake. Predator, They took out that rebel base and showed what they could do. They weren't slaughterd like the Marines in ALIENS but were eventually picked off one by one until. Voted for the Marines from Predator.

[RedAce]

I am going to have to say its a tie.....

Predator was fighting in the jungle which in a sence is "Home" advantage
Alien was fighting in tight, dark hallways which is their "Home" advantage

Since the Predator is 'Home" no matter who fought it, the Predator Marines or the Colonial Marines, the Predator would win.

same with the Alien, since the Alien is 'Home" no matter who fought it, the Predator Marines or the Colonial Marines, the Alien would win.

Its kinda unfair to compare them since they are so diffrent and no one can take a predator on in the Forest, and no one can take an ALien hive in a dark hallway

Now if the CM and the Predator Marines would fight, the CM would win because of technology

(I voted for the CM)

[Chris!(($$))!]

Even if they were evened out in technology. The CM has more in their Squad.

[CHAINS]

I don't know, it does look like a tie.

[RedAce]

it really is a matter of opinion, but everyone has pros and cons and is better in some locations then others

[Ripley]

You DON'T fuck with the Guvnor.